Pasture-Raised Cattle Better for the Environment Than CAFO Cattle

Research by the USDA on systems of caring for dairy cattle shows that a pasture-raised herd improves air and water quality significantly when compared to cattle in a confined animal-feeding operation (CAFO).

The Study

The USDA used a computer model to compare the environmental impact of four herds: two raised entirely indoors, one that spent seven months on pasture and the rest of the year inside, and one raised entirely on pasture. The amount of pollution by each herd was calculated over a 25-year period.

Typically, CAFO dairy cattle produce around 20,000 pounds of milk per cow per year, while pasture-raised cattle produce significantly less. The researchers adjusted the size of the herds so that each herd produced the same amount of milk.

The smallest herd was an indoor herd of 80 large Holsteins producing 22,000 pounds of milk per cow and 76 replacement heifers. The largest herd was an outdoor herd of 130 small Holstein-Jersey crosses producing 13,000 pounds of milk per cow and 95 replacement heifers.

The Results

  • Total emissions for methane, nitrous oxide, and carbon dioxide was 8% lower in the year-round outdoor system than in the CAFO
  • Ammonia emissions were 30% lower in the year-round outdoor system.
  • Perennial grasslands for grazing have carbon sequestration levels up to 3400 pounds per acre each year, while acreage used for feed crops had virtually none.
  • Outdoor cattle caused 87% less erosion than indoor cattle.

The study only looked at the effect of grazing systems and manure management on the environment. It’s not the first study on this topic, but it helps when government scientists and independent scientists agree. Other reasons to prefer pasture-based systems include animal welfare problems and antibiotic overuse in CAFOs and the better nutritional profile of milk from grass-fed cattle.

Image by Tasteach56, used with Creative Commons license.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top