Budget Cuts and Food Safety Testing

Looseleaf baby spinach In this time of austerity, everyone in Washington is looking for ways to cut costs. One way to cut costs is to get rid of food safety testing.

Microbiological Data Program

The Microbiological Data Program (MDP) is a program in the USDA that tests fresh produce for pathogens, such as e. coli, salmonella, and listeria. Its current annual budget is about five million dollars.

Even with this tiny budget, the MDP has been quite effective. The program focuses on β€œhigh-risk” produce – produce that has been implicated in a major outbreak – like alfalfa sprouts, cilantro, green onions, peppers, tomatoes, and leafy greens.

Industry Efforts at Food Safety

The United Fresh Produce Association and other major trade associations have been pushing the USDA to stop the Microbiological Data Program. They say it has cost growers millions of dollars in produce recalls.

The MDP has been responsible for recalls where there has been no outbreak of illness. The company press releases usually say something like, β€œout of an abundance of caution, we are recalling…” While there’s no guarantee that someone will get sick from contaminated produce, an abundance of caution seems reasonable.

Industry groups also point to efforts at self-policing. I’m all for the industry taking it upon themselves to improve growing conditions and safety procedures at processing and packing plants. I think it can be done while the MDP exists. If there comes a time when the MDP isn’t finding any pathogens, then it might be a good idea to cut the program. That time isn’t now.

Agency Overlap?

Currently, there is no other program like the MDP. The Food Safety Modernization Act will give the FDA more tools to combat foodborne illness, but its focus is prevention of outbreaks through more frequent inspection of processors and producers and research to find better methods of preparing, processing, and storing foods.

The CDC tracks outbreaks once they occur. Without the information gathered by the MDP, the CDC would be starting from scratch in determining the source of an outbreak. It would take longer to find the source and potentially more people would fall ill or die.

A program like the Microbiological Data Program would be outside the scope of the CDC. It could fit within the FDA, but their budgets are tight, too.

The MDP is already running efficiently and effectively. This is one of those cases where the old saw β€œIf it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” applies.

Spinach photo via Shutterstock

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.