Food Politics + Justice energy drinks

Published on February 28th, 2014 | by Jill Ettinger

1

How Safe Really are Substances ‘Generally Recognized as Safe’ by FDA?

How Safe Really are Substances 'Generally Recognized as Safe' by FDA?

What does “Generally Recognized as Safe” mean? Not a whole lot, according to some food safety advocates.

“Generally recognized as safe” (GRAS) is a distinction the FDA gives to certain food products as criteria for  allowing them into our processed foods. The other two ways ingredients wind up in our food is as a food additive or as an exception to food regulations. But some advocacy groups are now questioning the definition of “Generally Recognized as Safe” and the ingredients allowed under that umbrella.

Food Safety News reports that groups including The Pew Charitable Trusts and the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) are aiming to reform the regulatory process that includes GRAS processes.

 “This system is fundamentally broken,”

said Tom Neltner, an expert on the GRAS process with Pew and now NRDC.

Pew is suggesting that the FDA update its science on substances allowed under GRAS and require companies “to submit GRAS notifications, and implement a systematic review process for existing GRAS substances,” reports Food Safety News.

“When a company hires people, whether consultants or employees, who make the safety decisions, then it’s a conflict of interest,” says Nelter. Not that companies would be intentionally deceiving the public or regulatory agencies and putting dangerous substances on the market, but he says there may be inherent bias about whether or not substances under the Generally Recognized as Safe umbrella are actually safe.

“Where you have both a lot of professional judgment and conflicts of interests, now you have a recipe for a problem, for bad decisions,” explains Neltner. “If you had wonderful data — if all these chemicals were robustly studied — then there is less room for professional judgment. But that’s not the case with GRAS.”

Robert McQuate, CEO of GRAS Associates, LLC told Food Safety News that the GRAS process doesn’t expose Americans to dangerous ingredients, and the FDA is constantly reviewing ingredients, particularly those that are controversial. “If FDA sees that there is an issue that adversely affects public health, even if [the substance] has previously enjoyed GRAS status, FDA does have the authority and capability to make changes,” he says.

FDA has reopened comments on the 1997 proposed GRAS rule, which outlines the GRAS program currently used by manufacturers, notes Food Safety News, “But FDA is not likely to make any changes or issue a final rule in the very near future. According to an FDA spokeswoman, FDA is aware of calls to finalize the proposed rule, but the agency is working on other priorities, including implementation of the Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) and nutrition-related activities.”

Image: simon le nippon






Keep up with the latest sustainable food news by signing up for our free newsletter. CLICK HERE to sign up!

Tags: , , , ,


About the Author

Jill Ettinger is co-director of Eat Drink Better. She is the senior editor at EcoSalon.com and OrganicAuthority.com. A focus on food, herbs, wellness and world cultural expressions, Jill explores what our shifting food, healing systems and creative landscapes will look, sound and taste like in the future. Stay in touch on Twitter @jillettinger and .



One Response to How Safe Really are Substances ‘Generally Recognized as Safe’ by FDA?

  1. Pingback: Eat Drink Better | Healthy recipes, good food: sustainable eats for a healthy lifestyle!

Back to Top ↑
  • Advertisements

  • Popular Posts


    Over-the-counter drugs might alleviate your allergy symptoms, but the side effects can be the pits. Try these food-based natural remedies for seasonal allergies instead!

    I love infographics. When I came across this one about what, how, and when to plant vegetables, I thought I’d share. Keep reading after the pic for a few of my own lessons learned.

    Herbal homemade soda is quite simple actually. Almost any herb can be used, and this lavender and lemon combination is cooling and refreshing!

    Do You Think Cilantro Tastes Like Soap? Here’s why.

    Putting a healthy meal together can be difficult on a busy weeknight. These quick, easy, healthy meals make even weeknight cooking a breeze.

    Looking for an all vegan grocery store? Even if you’re not lucky enough to have one in your town, there are lots of online options for vegan grocery shopping.

  • Advertisements

  • Search the IM Network

  • The content produced by this site is for entertainment purposes only. Opinions and comments published on this site may not be sanctioned by, and do not necessarily represent the views of Sustainable Enterprises Media, Inc., its owners, sponsors, affiliates, or subsidiaries.


Shares