GMO News

Published on January 27th, 2012 | by Tanya Sitton


Monsanto in Court: What’s the Big Deal?

Monsanto: seedy and greedyMonsanto likes to frame itself as a benevolent mastermind of food production: friend to the lowly farmer, and selfless guardian of the environment. Their web site proclaims through text and video that Monsanto Company is Comitted to Sustainable Agriculture. Monsanto’s TV commercials are filled with soft-focus feel-good images of children playing in green fields, as abundant crops sway gently in the summer breeze.


A smooth and well-funded PR department, a quasi-monopoly on GM technology, and aggressive legal tactics towards farmers who resist Monsanto’s stranglehold have bought ample success for the biotech Goliath. But recent lawsuits shine a harsh and unflattering light on Monsanto’s practices, as farmers and others around the country reach for a slingshot and take aim. Two court cases deserve close attention in the coming months, from ecovores and other conscientious consumers.

Nitro Residents vs. Monsanto: Dioxin Contamination

In West Virginia, mediation in December 2011 failed to avert a class action suit against Monsanto by residents of a town called Nitro. Residents allege Monsanto illegally burned dioxin waste at its Nitro chemical plant, covering the town with toxic soot and unsafe levels of dioxin contamination. The case was initially filed in 2004, and the trial finally began earlier this month. biohazard warningAnywhere from 5,000 to 80,000 residents are suing Monsanto for access to medical monitoring, to assess potentially serious health effects caused by long term dioxin exposure following unsafe disposal. They hoped to hold Monsanto accountable for cleaning up the toxic chemicals contaminating their town, but that part of the case was recently thrown out. So according to the West Virginia Gazette,

Putnam County jurors will decide only if current and former Nitro residents should receive medical monitoring to detect diseases potentially caused by exposure to Monsanto’s dioxin. They won’t be able to do anything to clean up homes and businesses, ending the toxic exposure. Lawyers for thousands of residents and property owners in the class-action suit appealed [this decision]. They say the rulings left a huge gap in their efforts to deal with the legacy of Monsanto’s chemical-making operations. “The current presence of dioxin contamination in the class area is a public-health hazard,” the lawyers argued in court documents. “It makes little sense to initiate a medical monitoring program for a population without first eliminating that population’s exposure to the toxin at issue.” Thanks to Monsanto’s maneuvering, the jury will not be allowed to consider issues surrounding the need (or cost) of environmental cleanup, to limit further exposure.

Originally the company that gave us such destructive chemical products as Agent Orange, dioxin, and PCBs, Monsanto now controls 70 to 90 percent of global food production. Monsanto has a long history of unethical and deceptive corporate conduct — a tradition that’s alive and well in their handling of the Nitro dioxin case. They clearly expect to pollute with impunity, and endanger health without consequence. Monsanto’s actions here refute their rosy PR self-portrait, and deserve consumer notice.

Next>> Organic Farmers vs. Monsanto: GMO Contamination

Keep up with the latest sustainable food news by signing up for our free newsletter. CLICK HERE to sign up!

Tags: , , , , ,

About the Author

is an ecovore, veganist, messy chef, green girl, food revolutionary, and general free-thinkin' rabble-rouser. M.S. in a health profession, with strong interests in biology, nutrition, and healthy living - find her on .

6 Responses to Monsanto in Court: What’s the Big Deal?

  1. Roni says:

    I agree that “an informed consumer base is the only solution” -so thanks for covering this. Monsanto is being sued by India’s national diversity authority for violating biodiversity protection laws; the case illuminates Monsanto’s practice of bribing officials in order to circumvent environmental restrictions. They (and the other big GMO players like Dupont, Bayer and Dow) are doing damage in the name of profits that cannot be undone.

    • Tanya Sitton says:

      I’ve heard some arguments for some biotech applications that might be a ‘maybe’, given best possible management practices; but anything involving Monsanto in any way automatically gets a resounding ‘NO!!!!’, imo… they’re just too completely consistent in their behavior– and I definitely don’t mean that as a compliment!

      Thanks for your comment– I knew they had problems in India, but wasn’t aware of that case. Maybe somehow someone somewhere will find a way to extract some small trace of accountability from them, for some small part of the trouble they cause the world. Here’s hopin’, right?!

      Thanks again for the input! :-)

      • Dee Esseff says:

        One implication of this growing push-back in the US is certainly that Monsanto is focusing more and more on other parts of the world where regulatory regimes (where they exist at all) are even more inadequate that the lame one we have in the States. India is one example, and Mexico is on its way to being another.

        • Tanya Sitton says:

          Yep — I think it’s interesting how some of those ‘markets’ (aka people, farmers, and communities) are doing better than others at fending them off… blatantly problematic corporate ethics abound, in the active pushing of products known to cause problems for third world farmers (google ‘india Bt suicide’ or ‘Roundup resistant weeds’ or ‘Africa Monsanto biodiversity’)… Shocking that Monsanto would be so badly behaved! (<–sarcasm)

  2. Pingback: GMO Food Labels: Progress in 2012?

  3. Pingback: Scientists: Despite Industry Hype, Monsanto Fails at Sustainable Agriculture

Back to Top ↑
  • Support our Site!

  • Advertisement

  • Let’s Connect!

  • Advertisement

  • Popular Posts & Pages

    Whether you are looking to completely give up animal products or just want to try eating vegan some of the time, we want to support you! Below, you’ll find articles answering some common questions about vegan cooking and nutrition. If you don’t see your question answered below, please get in touch with us! We are happy to investigate for you!

    Find out what's in season now, plus get plenty of recipe inspiration to help you make the most of every season's beautiful, local fare.

    I love infographics. When I came across this one about what, how, and when to plant vegetables, I thought I’d share. Keep reading after the pic for a few of my own lessons learned.

    Top Sustainable Food Jobs of the Week.

    Looking for an all vegan grocery store? Even if you’re not lucky enough to have one in your town, there are lots of online options for vegan grocery shopping.

  • Advertisement

  • Search the IM Network

  • The content produced by this site is for entertainment purposes only. Opinions and comments published on this site may not be sanctioned by, and do not necessarily represent the views of Sustainable Enterprises Media, Inc., its owners, sponsors, affiliates, or subsidiaries.